A sales performance improvement plan should do more than announce that a rep is behind quota. It should show what is falling short, identify the part the rep can influence, and spell out how the manager will help the rep improve. When the plan is formal or could affect employment, coordinate with HR and follow your organization’s policies before presenting it.
At its core, an effective plan combines evidence, a focused target, practical support, and scheduled reviews.
Decide whether a plan is the right tool
First distinguish a performance gap from a temporary result. A rep can miss a quarterly number because of a thin territory, a delayed customer decision, poor lead quality, a pricing change, or a skill issue. A formal plan should not use a number the rep cannot reasonably control as its only test.
Review the sales motion and the rep’s history before setting expectations. Compare similar roles, territories, tenure, and opportunity mix. Look at where deals are lost or stalled, then ask the rep what they believe is getting in the way. If expectations were unclear, leads or tools were inadequate, or the process changed, resolve those issues as part of the plan rather than treating them as personal shortcomings.
A development plan and a formal performance improvement plan are not automatically the same thing. A manager may use a coaching plan to improve one skill without starting a disciplinary process. If the organization intends a formal PIP, involve HR early, use approved language, and explain the process and consequences consistently.
Write the gap as observable evidence
Replace labels such as “not strategic,” “poor attitude,” or “needs to sell harder” with dated examples and relevant measures. State the expectation, what happened, and the effect on the buyer or business. SHRM’s guidance on performance improvement plans likewise recommends specific incidents rather than broad summaries, and expectations tied to matters within the employee’s control.
For example, a manager might document that in six of the last eight qualified discovery calls, the rep presented a solution before confirming the buyer’s decision process. Include the call dates or CRM records and explain why that matters, such as proposals going to contacts without approval authority. Keep the wording factual, private, and limited to the issue the plan will address.
Choose one primary outcome and a few behaviors
Keep the plan narrow enough to practice. Choose one business outcome, such as improving discovery-to-qualified-opportunity conversion, and two or three behaviors that can plausibly affect it. HubSpot’s sales coaching guidance recommends diagnosing the individual rep’s gap with performance data, then setting goals tied to observable behavior rather than relying only on a broad result like “close more deals.”
Make the target specific, achievable, and time-bound. A sample goal could be: “Over the next 60 days, raise the share of qualified discovery calls that advance to a mutually agreed next step from the current baseline of 40% to 55%, while documenting the buyer’s problem, decision process, and next action in the CRM.” The figures are an example, not a universal benchmark. Set the actual target from the team’s data and the rep’s opportunity mix.
Translate the outcome into controllable practice commitments. For example, the rep may review two calls each week, practice one discovery scenario with the manager, and use a short checklist to confirm problem, impact, stakeholders, and next step. Avoid measuring activity for its own sake; each behavior should connect to the performance gap.
Put the agreement in writing
A practical sales performance improvement plan should fit on a few readable pages. Include:
- Baseline and evidence: the relevant dates, examples, measures, and role expectations.
- Success criteria: the target outcome, observable behaviors, data source, and review dates.
- Rep actions: the specific practice and customer-facing actions expected before each checkpoint.
- Manager support: coaching time, call feedback, product or process training, tools, and access to a peer example.
- Review process: the schedule for check-ins, how progress is documented, and what happens at the end.
Do not promise support that the manager cannot deliver. A plan that requires call reviews, practice, and timely feedback needs calendar time reserved for those activities. Review the draft with HR if the document is formal or could affect the employee’s status.
Use weekly check-ins to change behavior
Hold a short weekly or biweekly meeting that is separate from the forecast review. Begin with the rep’s self-assessment, review one or two examples, practice a better response, and agree on a next action. Keep each conversation centered on the target behavior instead of reopening every performance issue at once.
Use a repeatable agenda:
- Evidence: What did the CRM, calls, or customer response show since the last meeting?
- Reflection: What does the rep think worked, and where did the conversation turn?
- Practice: What is one question, explanation, or next-step close to rehearse now?
- Commitment: What will the rep try, by when, and in which upcoming opportunities?
- Support: What will the manager deliver before the next check-in?
Afterward, send a brief factual summary with progress, examples, agreed actions, and any support provided. SHRM recommends regular weekly or biweekly feedback and written summaries during a PIP. If a check-in is missed, reschedule it promptly rather than letting the process become a document-only exercise.
Set a realistic 30/60/90-day review rhythm
Match the review period to the sales cycle and the behavior being changed. Some habits can be observed within weeks; closed revenue may take longer. SHRM notes that plans should allow at least 30 days, with 60 or 90 days more customary. The right period depends on how quickly the rep has a fair chance to practice and demonstrate the required performance.
- First 30 days: confirm the baseline, remove access or knowledge blockers, practice the target skill, and review early examples.
- By day 60: check whether the behavior appears consistently in live opportunities and whether leading indicators are moving.
- By day 90, if appropriate: assess sustained performance against the agreed criteria, document the outcome, and decide the next step under company policy.
At each checkpoint, distinguish effort, behavior, and results. If the rep is practicing but the behavior is not improving, adjust the coaching method. If behavior improves but the outcome does not, investigate territory, deal mix, or other constraints before drawing a conclusion.
Make the result fair and actionable
At the close, compare the evidence with the written expectations, not with a new standard introduced at the last minute. Recognize improvements specifically, identify any remaining gap, and communicate the decision and next steps in line with policy. If circumstances materially changed during the period, document them and consult HR on how to proceed.
The best plan creates a clear chance to improve without pretending that a template can solve every performance problem. A focused goal, practical practice, manager follow-through, and consistent documentation make the process more useful for the rep and more reliable for the team.
If your team needs a faster, more repeatable way to build these skills, The Condor Club turns this exact process into a golf-themed, gamified microlearning course your reps will actually finish.